Bombay HC Upholds Cancellation of B.Tech Admission Over Tampered Scorecards

The Bombay High Court has refused to restore the provisional admission of a B.Tech student after finding that the scorecards he relied upon were tampered with.

The student, Shubham Mangire, had challenged the cancellation of his provisional admission to a B.Tech Renewable Energy Engineering course.

Mangire had appeared for the MAH-MHT-CET 2026 PCM examination in April and May and was granted provisional admission on June 23 based on his scorecards.

However, the State CET Cell's investigation found that his actual overall percentiles were significantly lower than what he had claimed.

The court noted several discrepancies in the subject-wise scores as well and said the percentile figures shown in the disputed scorecards did not match the official examination data.

The supplementary report submitted by the CET Cell concluded that the scorecards produced by Mangire had been “tampered with / fabricated” and were not generated by the authority.

The court said it found no reason to disbelieve the report and clarified that it was not deciding whether Mangire himself had fabricated or knowingly used the documents.

The bench described the circumstances as “deeply disturbing” and said the integrity of examinations and authenticity of documents are essential when merit determines access to scarce educational opportunities.

The court held that Mangire had no legal right to continue in the course and upheld the university's decision to cancel his provisional admission.

The court warned that such practices cause injustice to students who compete honestly on the basis of their actual performance.

The decision highlights the importance of maintaining the integrity of the examination process and ensuring that students are admitted to courses based on their genuine merit.

The Bombay High Court's decision is a significant one, as it upholds the principle of fairness and transparency in the admission process.

The court's warning against the manipulation of examination records serves as a reminder to students and institutions alike of the importance of maintaining the highest standards of integrity in the pursuit of education.

In conclusion, the Bombay High Court's decision to uphold the cancellation of the student's provisional admission is a testament to the court's commitment to upholding the principles of fairness and transparency in the admission process.